I don''t know why I don't have a strong memory of The Island as being notably narrow, since I tend to spray the ball. Yet, it was my 17th and last round within 21 days on my recent fall trip to Ireland. I did play a few courses that arguably had better layouts/routings, well placed and designed green sites, and bunker placements. But, perhaps it was the sense of place - last Ireland round, played fairly well, and the views at sunset that cause me to say that while a bit more pricey than some, they were Euros well spent. The exceptional sunset view back across the Estuary to Malahide, and the sight of the steeple of St. Syl's (where I stayed immediately next door) some nice folk I was placed with including a New Jersey couple who the wife could really play, all added up to a rather magical round. No, it isn't up to the Portmarnock standard I was lucky enough to experience the year before. But, it has all the authentic coastal dunes, nicely presented and maintained course that you would be happy you paid up to play. My best shot of the day was a 4 metal 17 degree, to the demanding and long par 3, 13th that I made par. Perhaps that elevated my fondness for the course...
But not really, it is a lovely coastal dunes course without that subjective influence. And, the clubhouse staff was wonderful in every way. Cathy, a guest hospitality official literally took full control and responsibility to get my clubs shipped with "Luggage Forward" back to my home, filing out and affixing all paperwork and scheduling the prompt pickup of the courier so I could go on worry free with the rest of my trip, Dublin sightseeing and on to Italy.
BTW, Malahide is a no-brainer for a place to stay while visiting Dublin, IMO. Castle is a must see, and good pub/restaurants in the village. I stayed there two years in a row, with DART station an easy ride into the city. No need to drive/park car around Dublin. Only downer is DART stops running way too early in the evening, like around 11pm.