Golf Club Atlas
GolfClubAtlas.com => Golf Course Architecture => Topic started by: V_Halyard on April 20, 2023, 12:28:26 PM
-
This is the official sign up for the 2023 Midwest Mashie - Kirtland CC / Cleveland
Also, Enjoy Andy's most recent Fried Egg Post on the 2023 Mashie Site
https://www.instagram.com/p/CxLf34fxbAH/ (https://www.instagram.com/p/CxLf34fxbAH/)
October 11-12 2023
Schedule
Oct 11, 2023
Late Morning Arrivals Check in
11:30 / Noon Ish Tee Times - Four Ball (East Vs West)
The line of demarcation will likely move to somewhere east of the Mississippi
7pm ish Dinner at Kirtland / Discussion with club Mgmt and GCA/Nagle
Oct 12, 2023
Early Breakfast and Early AM Tee Times - Singles Matches
Post Round Lunch and Presentation of the Mashie for those not rushing off
Looking into Possible Pre-Play and Replay Rate and additional Rounds in the area. Stay tuned.
2023 Midwest Mashie - Kirtland CC / Cleveland October 11-12 2023 (Not a Sign Up)
The East now holds the Mashie. It is only only fitting that we head east of Lake Michigan to celebrate the reclamation of the Mashie by the East Team. Your Mashie committee is ecstatic to share that the Kirtland Country Club in Cleveland Ohio has graced the Midwest Mashie with two days of golf and camaraderie at their Charles Hugh Alison course. The club is in the final stages of a dramatic restoration led by Jim Nagle of Forse Design.
Any assemblage of Post-Covid Tee times is rare. Two days of tee times at a course with this level of active GCA is like getting group trail rides on two-horned unicorns. Add to that, there are a lot of GCA inspired events these days. No hate here as GCA Appreciation is a great thing for all of golf. Popularization of GCA appreciation has roots inside of this very organization. We actively applaud, celebrate, and participate in the currently wide demographic of groups holding GCA inspired outings. The fact the Mashie is still able to secure a two-day outing in this climate is a testament to our long history of GCA events, our reverence, and reputation of respect for both the architecture and access.
Thanks to peer pressure, Golf Archie Jimmy Nagle has confirmed that he will join us at the Mashie.
GCAtlas folks that have previously been to Kirtland will be fairly shocked by the transformation. Do not sign up here as we are still finalizing details but do stay tuned for updates. As is the current custom of the Mashie, previous attendees of multiple mashies are offered the chance to pre-register and they are listed below. We have ample room for attendees up to about 40 so join in as we would love to have you and there always seems to end up being room. We have also accommodated a few that have reached out across multiple digital media.
Only sign up on this thread by hitting reply. As always, make sure your GCA messaging contact is up to date as signup confirmations, fees and other details will be sent privately.
Best
V, George, Thurm, Criss and Pat
TO DATE: Here are the attendees: As of Oct 04 2023
1: Vaughn Halyard
2: Jeff Shelman
3: Criss Titschinger
4: George Freeman
5: Jason Thurman
6: Tyler Kearns
7: Jake Marvin
8: Steve Salmen
9: Bill Steele
10: Frank Sekulic
11: Morgan Clawson
12: Mike Treitler
13: Brad Hill
14: Joe Melchiors
15: John Mayhugh
16: Ken Fry
17: Dan Moore
18: Josh Woodward
19: Cal Carlisle
20: Joel Lahrman
21: Mark Studer
22: The Joe Bausch
23: Jay MickleStix
-
A very cool place. Don't know whether I'll be able to make it, but get GM Mark Petzing to show you Hugh Alison's original letter of engagement, handwritten by him on notepaper from the Statler Hotel in Cleveland (now an apartment block). If he was writing his own terms, safe to say the club was pretty keen to secure his services!
Adam
-
Outstanding!
-
9 years later, we return to the city where the East got its first win. This must be what Lebron felt like in the summer of 2014. Except he was coming off a loss in the NBA Finals (which, as you know, are widely considered the Midwest Mashie of Professional Basketball).
-
... two horned unicorns.
Wouldn't these technically be "bicorns"?
-
... two horned unicorns.
Wouldn't these technically be "bicorns"?
Pondering.
Perhaps, although I believe ”bi” possibly implies an assumption with regard to the 'x'-corn's sexual preferences.
I am however comfortable with "Multi-corn".
-
This sounds wonderful. I will certainly make it if I can.
Perhaps as a Committee member I should know this, but wanted ton confirm the rough outline of the event? Guessing afternoon round on the 11th, and morning-ish round on the 12th?
-
This sounds wonderful. I will certainly make it if I can.
Perhaps as a Committee member I should know this, but wanted ton confirm the rough outline of the event? Guessing afternoon round on the 11th, and morning-ish round on the 12th?
Correct - Anticipate a traditional Mashie Schedule
Oct 11, 2023
Late Morning Arrivals Check in
11:30 / Noon Ish Tee Times - Four Ball (East Vs West)
The line of demarcation will likely move to somewhere east of the Mississippi
7pm ish Dinner at Kirtland / Discussion with club Principals and GCA/Nagle
Oct 12, 2023
Early Breakfast and Early AM Tee Times - Singles Matches
Post Round Lunch and Presentation of the Mashie for those not rushing off
Looking into Possible PRe-Play and Replay Rate and additional Rounds in the area. Stay tuned.
-
Vaughn,
Manakiki Golf Course (D. Ross) is one exit away on I-90. I'm sure we could set something up over there. It's about a 10-minute drive from KCC.
-
I am in for this!
-
Awesome! I hope to make my triumphant return this year :)
-
I have had the good fortune to play KCC on a few occasions. It is a true gem. One of the best back nines you’ll ever have the chance to play. The Chagrin River bisects the back. For the ones fortunate to play the Mashie it’ll be a memorable experience. Enjoy!
-
Looking forward to the Midwest Mashie. Kirtland is always a great place to hangout and enjoy the course, Clubhouse, members and their triumvirate of professionals. Here are some of the details of the work that started late last Summer and is wrapping up this week. All of the bunkers have been rebuilt. In 2007 when we completed the last rebuild we didn't have the bunker construction materials (liners) we have today. That limited our abilities to raise the faces as was seen in many of the old photos of the course. This go around we were able to flash the faces significantly on the bunkers which has had a very dramatic impact on the course aesthetics. Alison certainly held true to his liking of deep, bold green side bunkers on many of the holes at KCC. Fairway bunkers were also rebuilt. Two added items were the complete rebuild of the 16th green where, while cleaning out the previous green, the team discovered the original clay tiles from the original green. This enabled us to rebuild the green at the elevation Alison intended. The front right and middle right of the 3rd green was altered to regain lost hole locations. For this par 3 the right side has been uncuppable for decades. These may be come some of the more challenging holes locations on the course. The 8th hole includes the reinstatement of a cross-bunker jutting into the right side of the fairway. The bunker was previously added to the left side. Thankfully, the membership bought into it being properly placed this go around. Roll-off was added left of the 8th green. Very little fairway expansions or alterations were added. Most of these were completed in 2016. However, the left side of the 14th fairway is likely to be expanded this Fall. Most of the greens were expanded in either 2007 or 2016. Structurally not much has changed at Kirtland. But, the aesthetics and playability of the bunkers has changed drastically. One added bonus was the reinstatement of a long thin bunker left of the 18th fairway along the fall-off into the woods. A culling of the trees between 4 & 5, 2, 7 & 8, and quite a few between 15 & 16 has really opened up portions of the property.
Looking forward to an opening day celebration in early May. Hope many of you can make it out for the Mashie.
I will post photos soon.
-
Great news!
-
We have the little sibling of Kirtland here in western New York. (https://www.golfwrx.com/709661/2023-pga-championship-preview-the-other-wny-club-that-hosted-the-pga/)
Park Club is quite reminiscent of its fellow Alison course, and is gentler in every facet: the presence of the river, the fierceness of the greens, the intensity of the vertical drop and rise.
Park does have a Wendehack clubhouse and a really cool 18th green approach. Ian Andrew did fine work rousting Park Club from slumber. I was at Kirtland in 2021, I believe. Loved it.
Still teaching and coaching, so I shan't be at the Mashie. Those who attend will enjoy themselves.
-
Any updates? Might have missed the sign up thread.
-
Was wondering about this also, was there a sign up thread?
-
We do have some space remaining in the event. If you'd like to join, reach out to me via PM and let me know your:
- Home location (for determining team East vs West, and verifying handicap)
- Approximate handicap
- Best e-mail address (for coordinating event details)
-
The sign up is live on this thread
-
Sign up on this thread only
-
I would like to partake in this event. Sign me up!
-
Another Mashie👏👏👏🤗
-
Mickle has been cleared from injured reserve and has joined the party.
-
Really really bummed to miss this one.
Next year!!!!
-
Also bummed to miss this one, but after a member-guest in North Carolina last weekend, and a Fried Egg event at Kingsley this weekend, I just couldn't swing another couple days off in such close proximity. Hope everyone has a great time.
-
With great regret I must withdraw due to misadventure.
I hope someone can be called up at this late date, if not tell me what I owe and I will gladly pay.
2023 has been a terrible year for golf. Boo.
-
Manakiki is a public Donald Ross layout with lots of openings the afternoon of the 10th. I have a time booked at 1:20. If you're looking to play Tuesday, let me know (here, by PM, or by email). I may have openings in my tee time, and there are plenty of adjacent times available for a mini-outing. I can help organize interested parties.
-
With great regret I must withdraw due to misadventure.
I hope someone can be called up at this late date, if not tell me what I owe and I will gladly pay.
2023 has been a terrible year for golf. Boo.
John so sorry to miss you.
You're good and if you need to heal, heal well!
V
-
Gentlemen, the rosters for each team. Please let me know asap if I'm missing anyone, or if anyone I've listed must bow out. Note that we currently have an odd number of players but we have a few different ways we've solved for that historically. There's no need for Team West to forfeit just because they didn't bring enough friends 8) :
[/size]Team East
[/size]Criss Titschinger
[/size]Jason Thurman
[/size]Jake Marvin
[/size]Steve Salmen
[/size]Bill Steele
[/size]Mike Treitler
[/size]Joe Melchiors
[/size]Jay Mickle
[/size]Ken Fry
[/size]Josh Woodward
[/size]Cal Carlisle
[/size]
[/size]Team West
[/size]
Vaughn Halyard
Jeff Shelman
George Freeman
Frank Sekulic
Morgan Clawson
Lou Duran
Dan Moore
Joel Lahrman
Joe Bausch
Drew May
-
So many terrific guys in attendance.
Wish I could have joined you. Enjoy, all!!
-
Gentlemen,
We will send out the first group around 1. Pairings will be made onsite as we work with arrival times. Note that Steele, Salmen, and Moore are late scratches. Expecting 9 players per team.
-
Men - a note for tomorrow: We will have breakfast served in the locker room tomorrow morning.
Current Standings
East ('22 winner) - 1.5 pts
West - 2.5 pts
8.5 pts to win
Pairings (West on left, East on right):
8:30
Joel vs Cal
Morgan vs Criss
8:40
Bausch vs Melchiors
Frank vs Ken
8:50
George vs Jake
Shelman vs Thurman
9
Vaughn vs Jay
Mark vs Treitler