Sven,
I may not be of huge assistance on this thread, but I want to let you know that I will be following intently. Should be a fascinating exercise.
Sven-I know Raynor gets the credit now for Essex Fells and remember reading that some felt Banks might have actually been the lead. Was it originally a Ross?
Sven-I know Raynor gets the credit now for Essex Fells and remember reading that some felt Banks might have actually been the lead. Was it originally a Ross?
Perhaps you are thinking of Essex County ( and Francis Byrne public course next door, formerly an asset of Essex Co.). Essex Co, NJ is a fine under-rated Raynor.
It is only 3.2 miles from Essex Fells, and there are other courses nearby, too, including Crestmont, and Montclair CC. Probably twenty other courses within 12 miles in Essex, Union and Morris Counties.
Being a Crane from NJ I should know this stuff !
I believe North Fork was declared the only Ross course on Long Island. Pretty amazing he didn't do more work there.
I believe North Fork was declared the only Ross course on Long Island. Pretty amazing he didn't do more work there.
That declaration would be wrong.
In regards to CC of Detroit, it opened in 1927 as new Alison course with new land. Those Ross features I believe do NOT exist. I believe Tony is out of town but this is his response from a prior thread regarding CCD. Tony Gholz is a C&H expert.
Hi Rich, hope this finds all well.
What modern digital technologies and insights are you referring to?
Thanks.
Sven,
Meadowbrook (Northville, MI), The 18th green is a Ross green and untouched. The 12th green is a Ross laser copied green and moved back during the recent Renovation. It's my favorite green on the course.
Sven,
Meadowbrook (Northville, MI), The 18th green is a Ross green and untouched. The 12th green is a Ross laser copied green and moved back during the recent Renovation. It's my favorite green on the course.
Did the 12th used to be the 14th? The article notes the 14th and 18th as Ross remodels, and it covers the changes to the 14th in great detail. It also notes that the hole in question was a two shot drive and pitch, which fits the 14th to a tee.
Sven
I'll go with the contemporaneous report that describes the hole as a two shotter.
Your favorite green there is a Park, not a Ross. Wouldn't be the first time a remodeling team had the wrong info.
Enough on this distraction. If you want to continue the conversation on this one hole out of the thousands Ross built, do it in another thread.
Sven
Quick side note to try to decipher a bit of a mystery.
In the 1920 listing above I noted Gross Ile and posted the Ross course plan which matches what is on the ground today. I also included a Aug. 29, 1920 Detroit Free Press ad for Golf View Estates on Grosse Ile, copied below.
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Grosse%20Ile%20-%20Detroit%20Free%20Press%20Aug.%2029%201920_zpsmg8or7w4.png)
If you look closely at the map in the ad, the location of the course noted is that of today's West Shore G&CC. West Shore is credited in some sources to George Ferry (with dates varying between 1908 and 1916). West Shore was also known as Island CC, as noted in the following article.
May 14, 1933 Detroit Free Press -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Grosse%20Ile%20-%20Detroit%20Free%20Press%20May%2014%201933_zpseg4xg9fl.png)
This article, along with the 1920 ad, seems to suggest that West Shore (f/k/a Island) was designed by Ross. This would make Ross responsible for both of the golf courses on Grosse Ile.
Sven
This leads me to believe these docs are really about The Island Club (Westshore)...the location in the ad confirms this as well.
Ciao
Sven
This leads me to believe these docs are really about The Island Club (Westshore)...the location in the ad confirms this as well.
Ciao
I think we're on the same page. All of the recently posted items are about The Island Club (West Shore). I don't think there are any mistakes in the articles, they just don't each individually tell the whole story.
The Island Club was going to be a real estate development, and the initial plans called for two 18 hole courses (the plan for the additional 18 seems to have been scrapped early on). A temporary 9 hole course was built by Ernest Way with the plan to have it replaced by the full 18 hole course designed by Ross and Hatch (not really a 9 and 9 situation, as the temporary course was replaced). What the articles don't mention but allude to is that Way was on site to manage the construction of the Ross plan, as he had done on a number of other projects.
Just down the road, William Connellan was managing the construction of the new Grosse Ile G&CC course for Ross.
Feb. 12, 1922 Detroit Free Press -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Grosse%20Ile%20-%20Detroit%20Free%20Press%20Feb.%2012%201922_zps0zx5keth.png)
Sean:
Further proof. Note the side by side articles on the two courses. We know Grosse Ile was a Ross, the plan says so. Now we know Island CC (West Shore) was as well.
Sven
April 8, 1923 Detroit Free Press -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Grosse%20IleWest%20Shore%20-%20Detroit%20Free%20Press%20April%208%201923_zpsvhdxb5bi.png)
Sven, do you have anything on what Ross did at Springfield in Ohio?He mentions it in reply #72 (year 1921)
When I first read the following article, I thought it might be a reference to Cheraw CC, but the location noted in the article doesn't quite fit.
This project also happened to be a development E.S. Draper was working on, according to a December 1925 report. There are a number of other stories discussing the club in the late 20's, 30's and 40's, but I haven't seen Ross mentioned again. Whether Ross designed the course or not is hard to say with my limited findings, but I thought I would bring it to the attention of this thread to see if anyone has more information on this course.
The DRS listing has entries for Elks CC in Worthington, OH (basically in Columbus) and Wyandot Golf Course in Centerburg, OH (a bit outside of Columbus). It notes the course in Worthington as Still in Existence, while it has the Centerburg course as NLE.
Elks CC was purchased in the early 1930's and renamed Wyandot CC, a club which survived into the 1950's before it went under.
There is still a Wyandot Golf Course in Centerburg. I have my doubts that it was ever a Ross course.
Highlands GC (Grand Rapids, MI) The 1930 Ross Booklet notes 18 Holes.The DRS listing has this as a new 18 hole course in 1927, but Ross was called in around 1915 to rework Bendelow's recently completed 18 holes.
This course closed in 2016 when it was purchased by the adjacent Blandford Nature Center:
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2017/02/highlands_golf_club_sold_to_bl.html (http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2017/02/highlands_golf_club_sold_to_bl.html)
Highlands GC (Grand Rapids, MI) The 1930 Ross Booklet notes 18 Holes.The DRS listing has this as a new 18 hole course in 1927, but Ross was called in around 1915 to rework Bendelow's recently completed 18 holes.
This course closed in 2016 when it was purchased by the adjacent Blandford Nature Center:
http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2017/02/highlands_golf_club_sold_to_bl.html (http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2017/02/highlands_golf_club_sold_to_bl.html)
Chris:
All of the information I've taken from the DRS Listing is from the version prior to the just released update (the latest version was released after this thread started). At some point I plan to annotate the thread with the updates that were made.
For your information, both Oakwood and Highlands are noted as NLE in the latest version (which I linked to earlier in the thread).
Sven
An older article noting Ross at Dornoch and describing some of the company he kept before jumping over the pond.
July 25, 1896 Aberdeen Journal -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Ross%20at%20Dornoch%20-%20Aberdeen%20Journal%20July%2025%201896_zpszqbyz7sz.png)
In the late teens and 1920's, during the motor tour craze, a number of automobile touring guides were printed. They often contained descriptions of golf courses you might pass along the way, as well as write-ups of other attractions.
One of those guidebooks was Rinaldi's Official Guide Book, published in 1920. This guide focused on the West Coast of Florida, and provided a good bit of information on the golf courses in the area at that time.
For the Fort Myers entry, the guide enlisted Donald Ross himself to describe the course. This is one of the few examples I've seen of a description of a Ross course in his own words. Today, the course still exists as the Fort Myers CC municipal course.
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Fort%20Myers%20-%20Rinaldis%20Official%20Guide%20Book%201920_zps6oiuf8v0.png)
To: Sven Nilsen and all students of Donald Ross,
Re: Hyannisport Club
In 1930-32, Donald J. Ross Associates delivered a routing map, field notes, hole sketches, and green sketches for the reconstruction of the golf course at the Hyannisport Club, and these documents appear to be the work of Walter Irving Johnson. However, I cannot find any information regarding a visit(s) by Donald Ross to Hyannis Port. Can anyone help me with this dilemma?
Thanks, Bill Healy
Added Mississauga G&CC in Ontario to the 1919 additions post.
June 21, 1919 Calgary Herald -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Rosedale%20-%20Calgary%20Herald%20June%2021%201919_zpsf0fdj8ye.png)
Two clips from 1918 and 1919 comparing Ross' income to other professionals:
Evening Public Ledger-February 19, 1918
(http://i1372.photobucket.com/albums/ag323/bretjlawrence/F3AD9D8D-C314-4DE3-85B4-6697D67F3A8D_zpszfhkltrk.jpg)
Evening Public Ledger-December 22, 1919
(http://i1372.photobucket.com/albums/ag323/bretjlawrence/490E70BF-7949-4261-8EC1-280964B0B06C_zpsh7w9blcm.jpg)
Sven -
About the articles above regarding the plans for various municipal courses in Atlanta, I don't think any of them were built. Ross didn't do a municipal course. If S&VK did one, which I doubt, the name has since changed.
The current site of P'tree GC would not have been one of the sites considered by Ross during his 1926 tour. It would have been too far north. My guess is that they were looking at sites near P'tree Battle Creek (then called P'tree Creek). It might be the current site of the Bobby Jones Golf Course, formerly a city course now redone and owned by the state, that has several holes on the creek.
Bob
Another unknown Ross project. The DRS notes Ross working at Palmetto in Aiken in 1928 (adding in an irrigation system). It makes sense that he visited Highland Park as well while this work was going on.
Nov. 1, 1929 Aiken Standard -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Highland%20Park%20-%20Aiken%20Standard%20Nov.%201%201929_zps8rb02ckf.png)
1934
Brightwood Golf & Country Club (Dartmouth, NS, CAN) - 9 Holes, New in 1934, Still in Existence
2018 DRS Update - Now noted as 9 Holes New in 1921 and 9 Holes Remodeled in 1921
Another Canadian project.
I note the reference in the Knoxville News-Sentinel (6.28.26) to the "famous" Ross course in Atlanta - Druid Hills!!! Another instance where the dog-didn't-bark. The more famous course in Atlanta at the time would have been East Lake, Bobby Jones' home course.
To: Sven Nilsen and all students of Donald Ross,
Re: Hyannisport Club
In 1930-32, Donald J. Ross Associates delivered a routing map, field notes, hole sketches, and green sketches for the reconstruction of the golf course at the Hyannisport Club, and these documents appear to be the work of Walter Irving Johnson. However, I cannot find any information regarding a visit(s) by Donald Ross to Hyannis Port. Can anyone help me with this dilemma?
Thanks, Bill Healy
Bill:
My apologies, as I owe you a response to your email (its been a busy couple of months). I don't have anything specific linking Ross to Hyannisport, but if anything pops up I'll pass it on.
The 1930-32 timing is interesting (and it should be noted the DRS lists 1936), as this would have been towards the tail end of Johnson's work with Ross, with the depression putting a dent in the work he was able to provide his associates. On one hand, Johnson was known to be Ross's primary draftsman, so there's a good chance any plans drawn up by Johnson originated in Ross's original notes and sketches. On the other hand, at this point Johnson had already done his own design work at Potowomut.
If forced to guess, if the items were delivered under the Donald Ross & Associates name, Ross probably had a good bit of involvement. Even late in his career, he was still making site visits, and Hyannisport was in his stomping grounds.
Sven
I reread Brad Klein's book on Ross this summer. It is a great read.
https://www.amazon.com/Discovering-Donald-Ross-Architect-Courses/dp/1886947554 (https://www.amazon.com/Discovering-Donald-Ross-Architect-Courses/dp/1886947554)
I wish this thread were pinned to the top of the message board. As the dean of "Your golf course is not a Donald Ross course" here in Florida, I reference it a lot.Don't drive angry...
Minneapolis Golf Club (Minneapolis, MN) - 18 Holes, Remodel in 1920, Still in Existence
Not included in the 1930 Ross Booklet.
June 24, 1920 Star Tribune -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Minneapolis%20GC%20-%20Star%20Tribune%20June%2024%201920_zps1nq0rbjn.png)
The Givens site has a map of the course, but the 1917 notation predates Ross' involvement.
Course Plan -
(http://i1211.photobucket.com/albums/cc435/snilsen7/Ross/Minneapolis%20GC%20Plan%20-%201917_zpspo8go2gg.jpg)