Golf Club Atlas
GolfClubAtlas.com => Golf Course Architecture => Topic started by: Chris Roselle on March 13, 2015, 11:49:06 AM
-
It is with much sadness that I report on the passing of James Finegan, Sr. Mr. Finegan was considered Philadelphia's golf historian and the book he penned for our Centennial is a classic. I'm sure many have had the chance to read his books on the courses of Scotland and Ireland. I personally will never forget the numerous times he would visit the GAP office and regal us with stories while researching the histories of Pine Valley GC and Aronimink GC.
http://gapgolf.org/charts.asp?sfile=static/archive/2015_james_finegan_sr_obit.html (http://gapgolf.org/charts.asp?sfile=static/archive/2015_james_finegan_sr_obit.html)
-
Very, very sad news. His books on the courses in the UK are amongst my favorites. May he rest in peace.
-
That is too bad to hear....although he lived a great golf-filled life!
I credit his books on Scotland, Ireland, and England with introducing me to the idea of overseas golf as a teenager, as I couldn't wait to run home from school to read where he played next.
A true hero to all of us armchair critics and golf trip planners!
-
It is indeed a sad day for the golfing world, although it comes as little surprise for Jim was in failing health of late..
I had the great fortune to play with Jim several times around his beloved Philadelphia area clubs and can honestly say they were among the most memorable of all my rounds. Jim was kind, energetic, infectiously passionate, a walking encyclopedia and a sheer joy to spend any time with. His stories and anecdotes were always interesting and usually riveting. The man lived and breathed the game and it's venues and history was his plasma.
We've lost a great one, but I know his memory will live on among all of us who were fortunate enough to know him. Rest comfortably in that big library above. We'll miss you! :'(
-
I had the pleasure of playing with Mr. Finegan at Llanerch in an event celebrating the 50th anniversary of the 1958 PGA Championship held there. His storytelling was off the charts, but what impressed me even more was his ability to hit driver off the deck at age 77! RIP.
-
I had the pleasure of meeting Jim at one of the Renaissance Cup events. Very nice man and, obviously, an excellent writer about golf courses. His books are a must have in any golf architecture library, but good luck trying to find a copy of his book on Philadelphia golf. I managed to do so a while back, but it sure wasn't easy.
Jim's writing deserves note for several reasons, but I will highlight just one. Far too often, when writing about a golf course, people describe how they played, what clubs they hit, what score they made, etc. in short, they think they are describing a golf hole, but they really aren't. They are simply telling us about their game.
Jim Finegan was unique, IMO, because he could include a description of playing the hole and still make his words be about the golf course, not the player.
-
Never met the man, but his books are among my most treasured golf book collections. A wonderfully under-stated writer -- his criticisms of a course were always even-handed, and respectful. (I played some courses that I otherwise would not have, under his recommendations in his book, and found his reviews spot-on.) I always thought his writing was a throwback to an earlier era, where the ability to carry on civil discussions was the mark of a real gentleman. I'm sure he will be missed by those who knew him well.
-
I wish we would have added an interview with him to the website. His books served as travel companions and guide before I was aware of this website.
-
I wish I could have met Jim. I reread his books regularly. In fact, I have given them to other guys as Christmas presents. I will miss him even if I never met him.
-
Great writer, impeccable researcher, and an editor's nightmare because he never wrote to the appointed space. Thank goodness. We are all the better off for having read him on Philly golf, on GB&I, on anything he touched.
-
His books were and are a great resource!
RIP
-
I was Jim's editor at T+L Golf. He and I became good friends and played many rounds together over the last decade of his life, including Machrihanish and TOC in 2012, which I'm pretty sure was his final trip across the pond. We had a lot of laughs, and boy could he play, even well into his 80s. No one loved golf more than Jim. He was one of the best companions on the course you could ask for...if you hit a good shot you'd get:
"Never in your LIFE, sir...!"
I'm crushed right now and having trouble finding words, but I just feel so fortunate to have known him. He was, and always will be, a huge inspiration in my own life as a writer. Nate Oxman is right--he was a great storyteller, but there are just as many great stories *about* Jim. I hope to see some of you next week in Philadelphia to share them and celebrate his wonderful life.
Rest in peace.
-
Every word of his prose was beautifully, lovingly textured; after putting his books on Scotland and Ireland down, it was necessary to shake the sand out of my hair and pick the gorse thorns from my pant legs. Absolutely my favorite golf writer since Darwin himself. What a loss, but what a fantastic ride he had!
-
Brad Klein,
"1,500 words?! I need 1,500 words just to CLEAR MY THROAT!"
;D
-
I didn't know the first thing about golf in GB&I, aside from those on the Rota, until I picked up his books. Might be a good time to pull them off the shelf again.
-
GAP feature video 'Philadelphia Golf Legends' on Mr. Finegan and his 'Centennial Tribute to Philly Golf' book:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ioD3I3duHI&feature=youtu.be
Another GAP feature video about Mr. Finegan's early golf days, caddying, college career:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b88eWwqKDso&feature=youtu.be
He talks about being the #1 player for La Salle and beating Penn in 1951 before graduation. My uncle was on Penn's golf team then, but maybe only a sophomore. Will have to ask him if he has any recollections.
-
RIP James.
a big part of my Irish and Scottish travel pre internet and pre GCA.
-
I got to know Jim when he called to ask if I could help supply photos for one of his course profiles for the USGA GOLF JOURNAL ... back in the early 1980's none of the golf photographers had been to Brancaster or Swinley Forest. I ended up contributing the photos for several of his pieces there [and it was a nice payday at the time, too].
He was one of the most positive people I've ever met, and it was not hard to see that he was a natural fit for the advertising business! And, as Tom says, he loved golf as much as anyone I've known.
My favorite memory of his golf was when he came to play Black Forest and Crystal Downs 18-20 years ago. He could only hit the ball 175 yards but he could hit it on a rope. He shot 75 or 76 at Black Forest, never missing a shot on a course everyone else thinks is impossible. At the Downs, I remember he hit a solid drive on the short par-4 7th and then hit a great 3-wood to the front of the green ... where he was stymied by the ridge with the pin in the back right. I think the word he used was "scandalous". :)
I will really miss Jim Finegan.
-
Joe Logan's tribute:
http://myphillygolf.com/blogs.asp?blogid=1
-
Wayne Morrison asked me to post this video of Jim Finegan speaking at the 2006 Flynn Invitational @ Philly CC:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9KlRe391q7M
Enjoy!
-
I heard Jim speak once, in 2007, it remains vivid in my mind. His thoughts about North Berwick, his humor, and his personal warmth were all enjoyable to experience, for my friends and I.
-
Spent more than a few a few afternoons looping for Mr Finegan and must confess at first blush it felt like boot camp. Having plied my trade since age 11 , no doubt felt I had done my apprenticeship already . Thank goodness hid it well and got a repeat test. . It was akin to caddying for PJ Boatwright in many ways. If you passed muster and were able to get in the circle a treasure trove of golf knowledge awaited you .
Thank you for sharing your knowledge and love of the game with so many , and God Bless the Finegan family . RIP
-
Met the man once, in the PV clubhouse, where minutes before I had pulled my approach on 18 into the parking lot, taking out the rear window of a late model import. ( no joke.)
I had purchased a copy of his PV history book earlier, and Mr. Finnegan was kind enough to inscribe it. He wrote:
To Joel---Wonderful to meet you on such a smashing occasion!
RIP Jim.
-
Sorry to hear the news, I had the chance to meet Mr Finegan while in the Philly area, he made me feel like we had know each other for years.
I regret not taking the time to spend more time around him, he had so much wisdom to offer.
My condolences to the Finegan Family.
-
I read and reread his little books before, during and after my trips across the pond. They gave me the spirit to try GB&I travel as the first time 15 years ago it seemed daunting. May he rest in peace.
Greg
-
Jim cast a long, impressive, and colorful shadow on Philly golf and beyond. His writing, in works both big and small, had depth, insight and a flair unique to the man he was. The GB&I offerings are among my most well-worn golf books. I have also given additional copies as gifts, or lent my copies to friends preparing for their treks.
Many posters, and all who knew him, recognize the absolute love affair with the game he enjoyed and shared with countless folks during his rich life. Jim was also a caddie at one time...imagine that. Wonder where the bug that infected him came from?
Yet another shining example of the " quality" that single, greatest source of golf's champions and difference makers helped mold. Food for thought.
My sympathy to his family, and a tip of the flag from a fellow caddie.
Farewell Jim, and thank you for all you contributed to the game and the many lives you touched.
Respectfully,
Kris
-
http://www.golfwrx.com/288705/monday-tour-mash-a-new-golf-movie-turbulator-rap-and-more/
-
Love his books. I called him once to ask permission to send books to be signed. Had a great hour long conversation. What infectious enthusiasm he had for the game. Gib is spot on with the Darwin comparison. RIP Mr Finegan, thank you for your many contributions to the game. A life very well-lived!
-
One of my great regrets is that I never met Mr. Finegan in person, although like most here I have many of his books and therefore feel somehow that I know him.
His account of Cobb's Creek in his Centennial book of GAP set me searching for the truth about the origins and evolution of that course because he made it clear that he really didn't know all the details either. If he didn't, I was pretty sure no one did.
Some years later a mutual friend told me he was going to get a copy of our voluminous Cobb's Creek history book to Mr. Finegan and I'm uncertain if that ever happened. I like to think it did.
Somehow, I can imagine him looking at it and either saying, "are these guys crazy?", or like Rand Jerris, "my lord, what a copyright nightmare!"
-
One of my great regrets is that I never met Mr. Finegan in person, although like most here I have many of his books and therefore feel somehow that I know him.
His account of Cobb's Creek in his Centennial book of GAP set me searching for the truth about the origins and evolution of that course because he made it clear that he really didn't know all the details either. If he didn't, I was pretty sure no one did.
Some years later a mutual friend told me he was going to get a copy of our voluminous Cobb's Creek history book to Mr. Finegan and I'm uncertain if that ever happened. I like to think it did.
Somehow, I can imagine him looking at it and either saying, "are these guys crazy?", or like Rand Jerris, "my lord, what a copyright nightmare!"
Or after he lifted it: "I need some Doan's!"
-
;D
Mike C , I'm sure you and Mr Finegan would have been fast friends and if he got his hands on your book might know it as well,as you . You are kindred spirits in many ways!
-
Archie, you're way too kind. Thank you.