SITE SEARCH

GOLF COURSE DESIGN - 101

By

Dick Sayer

In June 1999, my wife Susan and I spent three days at Harvard studying golf course design under the tutelage of Geoffrey S. Cornish and Robert Muir Graves, two highly respected golf Architects, who are also co-authors of the textbook Golf Course Design. It was an enlightening experience, and we even learned a few things along the way.

Here are some basic design principles and other information gained from that session:

When developing a new golf course with practice areas and other ancillary facilities, you should acquire approximately 300 acres for the project.

You can get by with less, but it won't be a first class golf facility, and there’s something about having to wear a hard hat while playing a golf course that detracts from the overall experience.

To achieve maximum operational flexibility, both nines should start and end at the clubhouse.

This is not the case with the old Scottish links courses, such as St. Andrews, however, a good example of this operational principle, even with a links type design, is Pete Dye’s Ocean Course at Kiawah. Each nine runs 'outbound' and 'inbound' along the ocean but on opposite sides of the clubhouse.

Try to place any required 'out of bounds' restrictions on the left side of the fairway, and install cart paths along the right side of the hole.

National statistics show that a significantly higher percentage of golfers tend to slice rather than hook their tee shots.

Merion East’s 14th hole is a good example of out of bounds left, although I’ve put a few tee shots in the front yards neighboring that hole, but their second hole violates this design principle by having Ardmore Avenue on the right. I’ve heard stories about some of the golf ball and car collisions that occur at that location, and I almost caused two of them myself the last time I was there.

Design internal roadways for one-way traffic and try to have vehicles travel in the same direction as play on any adjacent golf holes.

A stray golf shot will do less damage if it’s traveling in the same direction as the vehicle it hits. I think this idea is rooted somewhere in the laws of Physics. In addition, following this design principle will lessen the chance of a golf ball becoming embedded in a driver’s forehead, which is not a pretty thought.

Regardless of how 'penal' a golf hole may appear, it’s not 'unfair' if the course designer provides you with a clearly visible way to get around the trouble. ( as spoken by Robert Muir Graves )

Pine Valley has numerous examples of this principle, however, playing around the trouble may also double the length of each hole. Their par 3 fifth hole is a notable exception, because you have to hit your tee shot 225 yards over a ravine with a lake at the bottom. The only way to avoid that clearly visible trouble is to put the ball in your pocket and walk to the green via the adjacent clubhouse driveway.

Another factor comes into play in these types of trouble situations, the male ego. It’s the 'I know I should play it safe, but I’m going for it anyway' syndrome that results in more triple bogies than the hazards on the course.

The most copied golf hole in the world is the 'Redan' Hole, which is number 15 on the West Links at North Berwick in Scotland. Built in 1832, this is a medium length par 3 with the green set diagonally to the direction of the tee shot and there's a hazard guarding the left side of the green.

William Flynn used the Redan hole on virtually every course he designed, and you can see examples of this at Huntingdon Valley’s hole number 3 and Manufacturer’s hole number 4. The 12th hole at Augusta National is somewhat similar to the Redan hole, however, the hazard, known to all as Ray's Creek, is to the right rather than to the left.

Here are some principles of golf course design they didn’t teach us at Harvard:

Yardage markers should always be placed in the rough, not in the middle of the fairways.

Most players spend more time in the rough than they do in the closely cut area of the golf course, and the people who always keep it in the fairway don’t need the yardage markers anyway, because they already know the distances.

The practice range should never be in close proximity to the club’s outside dining terrace.

When you’re slashing it all over the range, you don’t need your friends on the terrace giving you pointers, and you certainly don’t want to talk about your bad swing when you finally get to the lunch table.

Don’t put outdoor dining areas directly in the path of a slightly or grossly off-line golf shot.

One of the exciting moments I witnessed in golf occurred when a member of my foursome hit his approach shot to Philadelphia Cricket Club's 18th green, and it flew unimpeded onto the dining terrace beyond and to the left of the green. Unfortunately it was lunchtime, and diners all over the terrace had to 'duck and cover' to avoid the ricocheting missile.

The tee boxes for the men and women should be at least 100 yards apart on every third hole.

There’s always a joke that one guy wants to tell the other without having to drastically modify it for mixed company, and there are times when one needs to relieve a variety of gastro-intestinal pressures without having to say 'excuse me'.

The study of golf courses and their design is fascinating, because while each Architect has his or her own ideas about what a golf course should be, there are a number of basic principles that apply to golf course design in general. For additional information on golf course design, check out the American Society of Golf Course Architects website at www.golfdesign.org.

Ó Henry D. Sayer September 12, 2000

 
ARCHITECTURE TIMELINE COURSES BY COUNTRY FEATURE INTERVIEW THE NEXT FIFTY DISCUSSION GROUP IN MY OPINION MY HOME COURSE ART & ARCHITECTURE CONTRIBUTIONS

© Copyright GCA 1999 - 2000. All rights reserved.